Picture supply: Getty Pictures
There has solely been one winner between Sainsbury’s (LSE: SBRY) and Tesco (LSE: TSCO) shares prior to now yr. The previous is up 11% whereas the latter has jumped 28%. Sainsbury’s has a better dividend yield, however that wouldn’t have come shut to creating up the distinction.
Which one seems probably the most enticing transferring ahead? Right here’s my opinion.
Operational efficiency
In Q1, complete retail gross sales (excluding gasoline) at Sainsbury’s rose 4.9%, with grocery gross sales up 5%. This era marked its highest market share since 2016, as its ‘Aldi Worth Match’ scheme and Style the Distinction premium ranges proved fashionable.
Argos grew 4.4%, regardless of a difficult market, and womenswear was up 13%. General, like-for-like gross sales rose 4.7%.
In the meantime, the full-year revenue outlook stays regular, with the corporate aiming for £1bn in retail underlying working revenue and £500m+ in free money circulate. Value financial savings are additionally on observe, with £1bn focused by March 2027.
As for Tesco, the UK’s main grocery store noticed its Q1 gross sales rise 4.6%, with UK gross sales up 5.1% on a like-for-like foundation. Its market share now stands at a commanding 28.3%.
The contemporary meals and premium ranges carried out nicely, with Most interesting vary gross sales up 18%. Wholesale enterprise Booker additionally loved stable development, regardless of a decline in tobacco gross sales. Eire (+5.5%) and Central Europe (+4.1%) posted sturdy development too.
Wanting ahead, administration maintained full-year steerage, with £2.7bn–£3.0bn in adjusted working revenue anticipated. And Tesco continued its £1.45bn share buyback, with round a 3rd already accomplished.
In brief, each FTSE 100 supermarkets have been performing nicely to this point this yr. I discover it onerous to separate them, actually.
Revenue prospects
Turning to dividends, Sainsbury’s presents a better yield than Tesco shares, which is unsurprising given the distinction in share value efficiency. As Tesco has motored increased, the yield has fallen as a result of inverse relationship between share value and dividend yield.
For this fiscal yr ending March 2026, Sainsbury’s is forecast to dish out 14.1p per share. That may be a 4% rise yr on yr.
Nevertheless, following the sale of Sainsbury’s Financial institution, there can be a particular dividend on prime later this yr. Together with this, the payout jumps to 18.5 per share, which leads to a forecast 6.1% yield. This may then normalise to five% the yr after.
In the meantime, Tesco’s forecast yield is decrease at 3.2%, rising to three.8% subsequent yr.
In fact, these are simply projections and never set in stone. Dividends are by no means assured.
Based mostly on this although, Sainsbury’s is arguably the extra enticing inventory relating to near-term earnings. It’s additionally barely cheaper, with a ahead price-to-earnings ratio of 12 in comparison with Tesco’s 14 (each for subsequent yr).
My decide
Naturally, there are dangers. The principle one I see is the potential of an all-out value conflict between the supermarkets. This hasn’t occurred but, however there was some chest-thumping phrases from Asda about taking again market share.
The issue with that is that supermarkets function with skinny revenue margins, so the very last thing Tesco and Sainsbury’s would need is extreme trolley wars.
I like Tesco’s market-leading place and future passive earnings prospects. However given the dangers, I’m not eager so as to add both inventory to my ISA proper now.
