Picture supply: Getty Pictures
The Card Manufacturing unit (LSE:CARD) share worth fell sharply in early buying and selling as we speak (7 Might), after asserting its outcomes for the 12 months ended 31 January 2025 (FY25).
Claiming to be the “first option to rejoice all life’s moments”, the group reported a 6.2% improve in income and a 2.3% fall in revenue earlier than tax (PBT), in comparison with FY24.
However adjusted PBT was £1.9m increased than its statutory equal. This may not sound like quite a bit however adjusting for these one-off objects means the group’s capable of report a rise in adjusted earnings per share (EPS) from 13.5p to 14.3p. On a statutory (accounting) foundation, EPS fell by 1.4p.
The inventory now trades on 6.5 occasions adjusted earnings. That is low by historic requirements.
Earnings traders shall be happy that the dividend has been elevated by 0.3p to 4.8p. This morning’s pullback within the share worth means the inventory’s now yielding just over 5%. In fact, payouts are by no means assured.
Wanting forward, the group’s anticipating to ship “mid-to-high single-digit share will increase” in adjusted PBT for FY26. It’s looking for to enter the American marketplace for the primary time and increase its buying and selling relationships with its abroad companions.
Not like many firms, Card Manufacturing unit’s capable of report: “We presently don’t count on there to be a fabric impression from tariffs on the group’s monetary efficiency in FY26.”
| Metric | FY21 | FY22 | FY23 | FY24 | FY25 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Income (£m) | 285 | 364 | 463 | 511 | 543 |
| EBITDA (£m) | 46 | 86 | 112 | 123 | 128 |
| Revenue earlier than tax (£m) | (16) | 11 | 52 | 66 | 64 |
| Internet debt (£m) | 108 | 74 | 57 | 34 | 59 |
| Fundamental earnings per share (pence) | (4.0) | 2.4 | 12.9 | 14.4 | 13.8 |
| Shops | 1,016 | 1,020 | 1,032 | 1,058 | 1,090 |
A complicated response
With rising gross sales, elevated earnings (albeit on an adjusted foundation) and additional development anticipated this 12 months, the group seems to be in fine condition.
That’s why as we speak’s share worth response – after recovering a few of its earlier losses, it was down about 3% by 10am – appears odd to me. What had been traders anticipating? Previous to the announcement, the corporate was indicating that all the pieces was going to plan and that buying and selling was consistent with expectations. Its FY25 outcomes confirmed this however the share worth nonetheless tanked.
Potential points
It could possibly be that traders are involved concerning the impression of the will increase within the Nationwide Dwelling Wage and employer’s Nationwide Insurance coverage. These are anticipated to price the group round £14m in FY26. However the administrators have factored this in to their forecasts.
One space to look at is the group’s borrowings. At 31 January, net debt (excluding leases) was £58.9m. That’s a £24.5m (71%) improve on a 12 months earlier.
On reflection, it appears to me as if Card Manufacturing unit’s a type of firms that’s ignored by traders as a result of it’s somewhat old school. It trades from over 1,000 bodily shops and derives little or no of its income from the web. Unusually for a corporation as of late, its outcomes announcement didn’t point out synthetic intelligence!
Ultimate ideas
Previous to as we speak’s outcomes, the common 12-month worth goal of the seven analysts overlaying the inventory was 154p. Even essentially the most pessimistic reckons the group’s price 120p. That’s a big premium to as we speak’s share worth of round 94p.
However over the previous 12 months, its share worth efficiency has been erratic. In September 2024, it fell 21.1% after releasing its interim outcomes. And it’s down once more as we speak.
On the face of it, Card Manufacturing unit appears to be a strong enterprise and has grown constantly in recent times. However I don’t need to make investments because it seems unloved and out-of-favour. I concern that its share worth isn’t going anyplace.
